Have you ever read something that just pleased you? Thrilled you? Made you want to read more?
Generally speaking in this editing game, I can find something good in every submission. It takes a lot of courage to put words on the page and more, to send them off for someone else to comment on. To that end, I think it’s important to point out the good, even in a rejection. A little encouragement doesn’t cost anyone after all.
But editors like to find that story that surprises them and makes them say ‘oh, this is going to be *good*’. The books that you talk about and tell people about long before they ever see a release date.
I found one today. I just hope the author agrees to the contract because, believe me, it’s going to be *good*.